LAKE ERIE, THE SHALE REEF IN THE YEAR 2000

         In terms of benthic studies and photography this year has been the worse in the last five or six years. The area has had much need steady rain over the spring and summer and the wave action has been detrimental to my getting down to the bottom of the reef very often. Perhaps too my getting older has something to do with it. When I first began this study four or five foot waves would not detered me from going out and getting samples. I enjoyed riding the surf and getting pounded by waves as I both swam out and tried to come back.

                                                                                  ROUNDED GOBIES

         They are still with us in what looks like a population density that is unchanged from what it has been the last several years. This doesn't surprise me. I had thought that the population would have collapse by now, but whenever I think something is going to happen I'm usually wrong. They're still down there doing their utmost to get into every picture I take. I still haven't figured out what their eating. The Zebra mussels are still found in what looks like the same density as they have been over the years.


 

     So many of the animals that were once present in large numbers have are still locally extinct. The several species of caddis flies (Trichoptera), all five species of snails, the planarians, while not extinct, are not the same species that was here before and the ones that are found are very rare.
             Below is a red colored planarian, one of the few planarians of any type seen.

        And while so many animals have disappeared the bryozoans seem to still be benefiting from their being gone. Two insects that one would think of as prime gobiy food, the midge larva, Ablabesymia and the mayfly larva, Stenonema, both seem to have maintained the same population density. How much the gobies are responsible for the changes in the make up of the biological communty I can't say, nevertheless this ain't the same Lake that I studied before they came.

                                                                                     ZEBRA MUSSELS

        In 1999 I saw no signs of spawning taking place. Till that year every fall small Zebra mussels would be found on the bottom of rocks. This year ( 2000) the mussels began spawning again. At first I thought the gobies were eating the young mussels which is why they didn't appear in the samples in 19990 but this must have been wrong and some other factor must have been in play in 1999 because the 2000 spawning was as evident as in other years before the coming of the gobies. To give an example of the spawning numbers I give the data from the first sample on which the young mussels were found.
     September 2nd, 2000 - the rock is triangular in shape measuring 9 cm. x 12 cm. x 11 cm.
Zebra mussels      126        They are found in three sizes rangeing from .5mm. to 2mm.
Ablabsymia nests   30
Bryozoan colonies- F. sultana    I can't tell if there is 1 or two colonies present.

       The young mussel were found on all the samples taken after this date.

                                                        Below a photo of a zebra mussel covered rock in the fall of 2000.


 

      I want to stress what I stated in the introduction about 90% of the reef is completely free of zebra mussels and looks likes the photo below.


                     (There are two sponges on the upper rock on the right and side. The sponge in the foreground is breaking up into gemmule bodies.)
 

                                                                                                  SPONGES

       The photos below of the two sponges were taken in the fall when the sponges were going into gemmule formation, regretfully the Lake waters were so full of suspended particles that I have no good photos of sponges in their mature state. It was I think a good year though for sponge growth, but it would be impossible for me to quantify their density in comparison with other years. The two photos give a good view of the struggle between the laison and the sponges. If you look closely at the edges where the sponge meets the laison you can almost feel the tension between the two life forms competing for space.
 


 


 

                                                                                          BENTHIC SAMPLES

          I am truly embaressed by the paltry number of samples taken this year. There are so few that I can present all of them below. Which such a small number it would be foolish to try to draw any meaningful conclusions about changes in the benthos compared to prior years. But I will make a few comments on what might have been changes in comparison to 1999.

                                                                                   HYDRAS AND PERITECHS
      My reason for combining these two radically different groups of animals are that they both are found in the same place and occur in their greatest numbers at the same time of year.    The number of hydras increased in the few samples taken with the greatest amount being found on a rock sampled on July 9. This is unusual as the hydras in prior years usually disappear from the samples in summer. Their numbers seem to be greater than in 1999.
      The zoothamniums have a loww population density as compared to the years when I first started studying the reef but this low density may be only a reflection of the fact I started the sampling in late spring.
          All the animals listed below were found on the rock's underside.
May 17th, 2000
          Second rock sample.  Rock size 6cm. X 12cm. from a depth of 8 feet.
                            Hydra americanus     8
                           Zoothamnium             4
         First rock sample        Rock size roughly about 35 sq. cm
                             Hydra americanus   1
                                                                                       BRYOZOANS
         The Bryozoan Fredericella sultana was as abundant as it has been over the last three years.
June 10th.
          Rock size 10cm. X 15 cm.
                       3  Byrozoan colonies, Fredericella.sultana. Two of them cover roughly 2cm. sq. the other is about 1cm. sq.
                       Colonial hydra, Cordaphyla lacrustris, colony covers an area about 1.5cm.sq
                       Hydra americanus         3

                       Ablabesymia nests   2
                       Planarian (photo in introductory page)        1
                       Zebra mussels        1        (10mm. long)

June 14,
        Rock size, very roughly, about 100 sq. cm.
                      Hydra americanus   27
                      Planarians (not Dugesia)    2
                     Zebra mussels                    2          (10 to 12 mm. long)
July 2
         Rock size, 4 cm. 15 cm.
                       Hydra americanus   19
                       Zoothamnium           7
         Rock 2  7cm.X 7 cm.
                       Hydra americanus  22

                    In the water that surrounded these rocks were found
                       Hydra americanus    17
                      Mayfly (Stenonema)   3             Body size 1mm. tail size 1mm.
July 6
     Rock size about 45 sq. cm.
                    Hydras                                    55
                    Zoothamnium                           2
                    Ablabesymia nest  (midges)      7
                                     In the water surrounding there were found
                                                 Hydras                            2
                                                 Harpactacoids               12
                                                Mayflies                          8
                                               Midges                           5
July 9
       Rock size about 64 sq. cm.
                   Hydras                                  9
                  Bryozoans F. sultana              3  colonies
                  Zebra mussels                        16              (2 small 1 to 2 mm.  14 large 8 to 12 mm.
                 Midge nests                              4
                                    In water around rock
                                                Mayflies                6
                                                Harpactacoids      5
                                                Midges                 2

Sept 2
       Rock size 54 Sq. cm.
                Zebra mussels   (spawning has taken place)           126              three sizes from .5mm. to 2mm.
                midge nests                                                             30
               Bryozoan colony                                                    1 or 2          couldn't tell if these two colonies were connected

Sept 10
      Rock size 180 sq. cm.
                 Zebra mussels       large  10 to 20 mm.                 7
                                             small    .5 to 1.5 mm.              60
                 Midge nests                                                        12
                 Hydra        a new species see photo in introductory section
Sept 20
      Rock size   96 sq. cm.
                Zebra mussels     large 8 to 20 mm.                    15
                                          small  <1 mm. to 2 m.             192
               midge nests                                                          3
               Bryozoan colony        covers roughly a 9 cm. sq. area
     Sponges seen on dive, they were abundant, still green in color, and none of them had gone into gemmule body formation.
Oct 11
       Rock size 90 cm.sq.
                Zebra mussels   4 to 6 mm.                                 5
                                        .5 to 2 mm                               97
                Zoothamniums                                                   4
                Hydra americanus                                              1
               Midge nests                                                        8
              Bryozoan colonies                                               3          "tentacles" visible in only one colony     F. sultana
Nov 1
         Rock size   54 sq. cm.
                 The red planarian (see above photo)
                 Zebra mussels          .5 to 1 mm.                   15
                Zoothamniums                                                5
               midge nests                                                     8

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------